...
Loans

Buying a New Jersey Sheriff Sale Property? Find Out Who Is Living There Before You Bid

Rundown New Jersey house with a Sheriff Sale sign on the lawn and a gavel resting on legal papers

I recently had a borrower reach out to me on a Saturday looking for financing for a sheriff sale in Somerset County, New Jersey.

The auction was Tuesday.

My first response was pretty simple:

“You know you’re not giving me much time to get you approved, right?”

He laughed. He knew.

The borrower was financially successful, had a strong overall profile, and the deal itself looked interesting. So I started digging in.

Then he gave me another piece of information.

He wanted to live in the house.

That changed things.

At VeeCasa Funding, much of what we arrange is business-purpose financing for real estate investors. If you’re buying a property to renovate, rent, build, or resell, there are hard-money and private lending options designed specifically for that world.

But when your intention is to occupy the property as your home, you’re walking into residential lending territory.

So I called my partner, Jahn Beckler of JahnLends.com, who is licensed to arrange residential mortgage financing.

Then We Tried to Pull Off the Impossible

Jahn and I basically spent Monday working the phones.

We reached out to private-capital relationships, wholesale lenders and anyone we thought might have a legitimate way to make the financing work within this extremely short window.

And somehow, we pulled the proverbial rabbit out of the hat.

We had an approval.

Considering this had started with a phone call on Saturday for a Tuesday sheriff sale, Jahn and I were feeling pretty good about ourselves.

High five.

Problem solved.

Or so we thought.

I got in my car and started driving home while talking to the borrower.

He asked me:

“So when can I move in?”

I started explaining the next steps.

“We still need the appraisal, title insurance, homeowners insurance and the rest of the closing items…”

He stopped me.

“I don’t think the old owners are going to let us in.”

What?

I asked the question that probably should have been asked before we ever discussed financing:

“You researched this property. It’s vacant, right?”

Silence.

Then:

“No.”

And that was basically the end of the story.

Winning the Auction Doesn’t Mean Someone Hands You an Empty House

This is the part that new sheriff-sale buyers sometimes misunderstand.

You are buying real estate through a legal foreclosure process. You are not ordering a vacant house from Amazon.

There can still be people living inside.

And those people can be the former homeowners, family members, legitimate tenants or other occupants. Who they are matters because their legal rights can be very different.

New Jersey’s own court materials recognize this exact situation. The Judiciary provides a specific procedure for a purchaser at a foreclosure sheriff sale seeking a Writ of Possession to remove a former property owner. In other words, purchasing the property and obtaining physical possession of it are not necessarily the same event.

That’s something you need to understand before you bid, not while you’re standing outside your newly purchased house wondering why someone else is making dinner inside.

This Is Where “Cash for Keys” Can Make Sense

There is another route that can sometimes be dramatically faster, cheaper and frankly more humane.

It’s commonly called cash for keys.

Instead of immediately turning the situation into a fight, the new owner and the former owner may reach a voluntary agreement.

The basic idea is simple:

The occupant agrees to move out by an agreed date, leave the property in an agreed condition and turn over possession. In exchange, the purchaser provides an agreed amount of relocation money.

Everybody knows the deadline. Everybody knows the terms. And everybody has an incentive to cooperate.

Handled properly, I think this can be one of those rare situations where everybody actually wins.

The investor avoids potentially lengthy possession proceedings, additional carrying costs and uncertainty.

The former owner gets some money to help with moving expenses, a security deposit, storage, a moving truck or whatever comes next.

And instead of an ugly confrontation at the end of an already difficult foreclosure, both sides have a path forward.

But Do It Properly

Cash for keys shouldn’t mean handing somebody $5,000 on the front porch and hoping they disappear next weekend.

This is where I would involve a New Jersey real estate attorney.

A properly prepared voluntary possession agreement can address things such as:

  • the exact date the property must be completely vacated;
  • the amount being paid;
  • when the money is released;
  • who must vacate;
  • removal of personal property and garbage;
  • the condition in which the house must be left;
  • surrender of keys, garage remotes and access codes;
  • a final walkthrough;
  • what happens if the occupant doesn’t perform under the agreement.

I personally would not want the relocation money fully released until the agreed conditions for surrendering possession had been satisfied.

The goal isn’t to pressure someone out of the property.

The goal is to create a voluntary, documented agreement that gives both parties certainty.

What If They Don’t Want Cash for Keys?

Then you don’t become your own sheriff.

Don’t change the locks while someone is living there.

Don’t shut off utilities to make the house uncomfortable.

Don’t throw somebody’s belongings onto the lawn.

Don’t assume that because you won an auction you can simply walk into the property and take possession.

New Jersey Courts explains that after a foreclosure sheriff sale, the legal process can include obtaining a Writ of Possession directing the sheriff to remove the former owner.

That’s the legal lane.

Let your attorney and the court system handle it.

And Make Sure You Know Whether You’re Dealing With an Owner or a Tenant

This distinction is extremely important in New Jersey.

A former homeowner occupying a property after foreclosure is one situation.

A legitimate residential tenant is another.

New Jersey’s Department of Community Affairs specifically warns purchasers that foreclosure by itself generally does not terminate a legitimate residential tenant’s rights. The state’s Anti-Eviction Act can protect tenants after foreclosure, and removal generally requires a lawful court process and legally recognized grounds.

So “someone lives there” isn’t enough information.

You need to know who lives there and under what circumstances.

That is a question for your attorney and your due-diligence team before you start making assumptions about possession.

There’s Another Clock Running After a New Jersey Sheriff Sale

Possession isn’t the only reason I tell investors not to treat the winning bid like a normal closing.

New Jersey also has a post-sale process.

New Jersey Court Rule 4:65-5 provides a period for objections following a sheriff sale, and New Jersey appellate decisions recognize the mortgagor’s equitable redemption rights during that process. A sale is generally automatically confirmed after the applicable ten-day period when no objection is filed, although particular circumstances and properly filed objections can affect what happens next.

Translation:

Don’t build your entire deal around the assumption that everything becomes simple the second the auctioneer says “sold.”

There are still legal, title, financing and possession issues to work through.

The Expensive Question We Should Have Asked First

Looking back at this deal, Jahn and I accomplished the difficult part.

We found the financing.

What we couldn’t finance away was the fact that somebody was still living in the house.

And that’s the lesson.

If you’re buying a New Jersey sheriff-sale property, before worrying about whether your lender can close quickly enough, you should be asking:

  • Who is currently occupying the property?
  • Is it vacant?
  • Is the occupant the former owner or a tenant?
  • Have I physically verified occupancy rather than assumed it?
  • What is my legal strategy for obtaining possession?
  • If voluntary relocation is appropriate, have I budgeted for cash for keys?
  • If voluntary relocation fails, have I discussed the possession process with a New Jersey attorney?

Because getting a great deal at auction isn’t a great deal if you haven’t figured out how you’re actually going to take possession of what you bought.

Finance the Deal, But Do the Homework First

I like sheriff-sale opportunities.

They can create tremendous opportunities for investors, particularly when a property has equity but needs a fast, nontraditional financing solution.

That’s exactly where bridge and hard-money financing can be extremely useful.

But financing is only one piece of the transaction.

At VeeCasa Funding, we can work on the capital side of the equation.

Your attorney can advise you on title, possession and the legal process.

And you, as the buyer, need to do the homework before raising your hand at the auction.

Sometimes the most important question in a multimillion-dollar real estate transaction is ridiculously simple:

“Is anybody still living in the house?”

Ask it before you bid.

This article is for general educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Foreclosure, possession, tenant rights and sheriff-sale procedures can depend on the specific facts of a transaction. Buyers should consult a qualified New Jersey attorney before bidding on or attempting to obtain possession of an occupied foreclosure property.

Scroll to Top
Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.